Another Previously Sold for $15,000; High-End Single Card Buyers Get a Little Reckless
A cosmic-treatment The Soul Stone card from the Magic: The Gathering – Marvel’s Spider-Man set has sold for $19,500 on eBay days after another Soul Stone sold for $15,000.
The world of selling strike-while-the-iron-is-hot non-serialized singles cards is getting weird out there. On September 21, 2025 a Cosmic Soul Stone, an ultra rare versions of the Soul Stone found in Marvel’s Spider-Man, sold twice on for $15,000. The two sales were from the same eBay profile with 0% positive feedback and a “0” rating, but the sales were tagged with an “Authenticity Guarantee” (meaning eBay authenticators will guarantee the item is real). The picture included in the listings seemed to be of the exact same card in the same holder positioned differently on the same table, so it is unclear whether or not both sales went through or this was just an incident where a novice seller doubled-up a listing.
The $19,500 sale came on September 25, 2025. This time the seller had a feedback rating of “15” with 0% positive feedback as a seller, but the item was tagged with an “Authenticity Guarantee.” There is yet another Cosmic Soul Stone listing on eBay for $25,000, which seems to have a better presentation with an actual video, a seller with 100% positive feedback, and the seller has an actual recorded sale of an item on the platform.
These recent sales place singles sellers and buyers in a very strange place. Aside from the sellers’ ratings being incredibly low (or zero) and the sketchiness of the doubled-up September 21 sale, buyers should really be questioning the numbers that these brand-new ultra rare cards are going for on the market. The Cosmic Soul Stones are not serialized, but they are rare as they appear in less than 1% of Collector Boosters. However, it is, thus far, unclear what the exact print run of Collector Booster packs are. Based on other similar sets (like LotR), the print run is likely in the millions after mass retailers get their share of Collector Booster products.
There could be under 100 of these cards out there, there could be thousands of these cards out there; no one really knows because the Cosmic Soul Stone card is not serialized. The Cosmic Soul Stones’ lack of a serial numbers also opens the door to easier illegal counterfeiting, once a skilled counterfeiter gets an hold of a original copy, as the quantity of these cards distributed across the world is unknown. These five-digit sales for Cosmic Soul Stones, at this point in time, seem somewhat reckless on the single card buyers’ end (unless the buyers actually are the aforementioned “skilled counterfeiters”; then, it’s probably just a potential “criminal business expense”).
Check out ICv2’s 2025 Magic: The Gathering product calendar for more information on future releases (see “‘Magic: The Gathering’ 2025 Release Calendar“).
Source: ICv2
